Credit Cards: Understanding the True Cost of Your Balances
Credit card debt is a major personal finance concern for Quebecers. With average interest rates of 19.99% to 29.99%, credit cards represent the most expensive form of debt after payday lending. Yet many consumers underestimate the real impact of these rates on their long-term financial situation, their credit score, and their mortgage borrowing capacity.
Typical Interest Rates in Canada
- Standard cards (Visa, Mastercard): 19.99% to 20.99%, the most common rate in Canada for regular-rate cards.
- Low-rate cards: 8.99% to 13.99%, in exchange for higher annual fees (generally $29 to $99 per year).
- Store cards (The Bay, Canadian Tire, etc.): 25.99% to 29.99%, among the highest rates on the market.
- Cards for higher-risk borrowers (limited credit): 25.99% to 29.99%, often offered to clients rebuilding credit.
- Cash advances: regular rate PLUS an additional 2% to 5%, with interest calculated from the day of the advance (no grace period).
The Minimum Payment Trap
The minimum payment is designed by card issuers to maximize interest revenue. Typically set at 2% to 3% of the balance (or $10, whichever is greater), it barely covers the monthly interest, leaving the principal virtually untouched. The issuer is required by Canadian regulation to display on each statement the time needed to repay the balance at the minimum payment. This figure is often shocking for consumers.
Impact on Mortgage Qualification
For borrowers seeking a mortgage, credit card debt is a major obstacle. Lenders typically include 3% of each card's balance in calculating the total debt service (TDS) ratio, which must not exceed 44% under OSFI guidelines (B-20). Even if you pay your balance in full each month, a balance reported to the credit bureau at the wrong time can affect your qualification. AMF-certified mortgage brokers in Quebec recommend keeping each card's utilization below 30% of the limit.
Effective Repayment Strategies
- Avalanche method: Rank your cards by interest rate, from highest to lowest. Make the minimum payment on all cards except the one with the highest rate, on which you pay the maximum possible. Once that card is repaid, apply the freed-up amount to the next one. This method minimizes total interest costs.
- Snowball method: Rank your cards by balance, from smallest to largest. Pay off the card with the smallest balance first for a quick win and to maintain motivation. The positive psychological effect can offset the additional interest cost compared to the avalanche method.
- Balance transfer: Transfer your balances to a card offering a promotional 0% rate for 6 to 12 months. Divide the total balance by the number of promotional months to déterminé the required monthly payment. Warning: a missed payment can retroactively cancel the promotional rate.
- Mortgage consolidation: If you are a homeowner with sufficient equity, mortgage refinancing or a HELOC can reduce your rates from 19%+ to 5-7%. Evaluate this option with your AMF-certified broker, considering refinancing costs and the risk of re-accumulation.
Consumer Rights in Quebec
In Quebec, the Consumer Protection Act (CPA) offers several protections to credit card holders. The issuer must clearly disclose the annual interest rate, fees, and conditions. The monthly statement must indicate the time required to repay the balance at the minimum payment. Consumers have the right to dispute unauthorized transactions. If you are experiencing financial difficulty, do not hesitate to contact your card issuer to negotiate a payment arrangement, or consult a non-profit credit counselling organization, such as ACEF (Association cooperative d'economie familiale), for free assistance.